She Said She Couldn't Pick Between The Two Of Us

It was a Friday night when Jenny invited Kyle and me over to her house. She was a friend, only 26, while Kyle and I were in our 30s. She was an old friend's ex, but when they broke up, he moved away, so she ended up staying friends with us. She has long blonde hair halfway down her back, piercing blue eyes, and a figure to die for.

We'd usually go over to hers every Friday evening for a takeaway and head out for a few drinks afterwards. Still, she wanted to have a movie night with us this time. We turned up with a few beers and dressed in comfy clothes. I had my joggers on, with a t-shirt, Kyle just a pair of shorts and a top. We were slightly surprised when we saw Jenny; she went for these cute little but sexy pyjama shorts, which showed off the bottom of her cheeks perfectly, along with a top.

"Those shorts look like something you'd wear for your boyfriend, Jenny!" I laughed.

"Oh, you don't like them then, Jay?"

"Oh, I do..."

"What about you, Kyle? Do you like them?"

"Shows your arse off perfectly, and you know I love your arse!" He laughed.

"Thanks! So you want a gin and tonic, boys?"

"Yes, go on then." I said.

"I'll have one too!"

Jenny walked off in her little shorts, and as she was sorting our drinks out, Kyle smiled and asked me whether I would fuck her given the chance.

"Would you?"

"Well, I don't think she likes either of us in that way, so what does it matter… But yes, I definitely would!"

"Me too!"

Just as we laughed, she came back with our drinks. Handing him his drink while bending over in front of me, then passing me mine and bending over in front of him. We couldn't keep a straight face, so it didn't take her long to notice the smiles.

"What are you boys smiling about? I heard what you said while I was in the kitchen, you know!"

"What did you hear, Jay, saying he would fuck you if he had the chance?" Kyle laughed.

"Oh, not that part; I heard him say I didn't like either of you in that way."

"So, you didn't hear Kyle say he would fuck you then?"

‘’No… But I've not had sex for a while. Maybe one of you can have it tonight."

The room went silent for a minute. I was sitting there thinking about what I needed to do to have a chance before Kyle gets in there, but Jenny had something in mind already.

"Let's play a game. I'll give you a couple of minutes each to seduce me. Whichever one turns me on the most, they get to fuck me tonight."

"I'm going first." Kyle said.

He walked up to her, turned her around and began kissing her neck from behind while caressing her tits through her top. He worked his hands down her body slowly, and just as he got her shorts down…

"Times up. Not bad, but your turn now, Jay."

I dropped my joggers, grabbed her hand and placed it on my already hard cock so she could feel what she would be getting if she chose me. I then lifted her top off, starting with some nipple play and then running my tongue down her body and across the front of her red, silky thong. She grabbed my hair and pushed me in closer. I slid her thong to one side, and just as I flicked her clit, time was up.

"I think I just want to fuck you both! Sex with two men has been a fantasy of mine!"

She pulled Kyle over towards me, pulled both our pants down and had a look at both of our sizes. With one hand, she began stroking me, and the other, stroking Kyle's cock. I decided to pull her thong down, dropping it to the floor. I pushed one finger straight inside her and a second shortly after while they were French kissing. She got down on her knees and began licking both cocks, alternating between the two, playing with our balls too.

"Sit down on the sofa, Jay. Let me slide on top of you. I want you to fuck my pussy."

She squatted down on top of my cock, with her arse facing Kyle.

"Kyle, I want you to put it in my arse. Spit on it and push it in slowly." She said, pulling her cheeks apart.

He began pushing in, but a bit too much. She started to scream, telling him to go slower, but he continued to push until he was eventually all the way in. She let out a big gasp and then gave me the go-ahead to start fucking her faster.

"Spank me, Kyle!"

He slapped her arse but in a weak way.

"Harder!!"

"Don't you dare cum inside me, Jay! Do it over my face if you're going to!"

"But I'm close already!"

I wasn't going to tell her I'd love to creampie her, but when she said to do it on her face, there was no other way for me. She climbed away from both cocks, and got on her knees in front of us. She then used both hands to wank us off at the same time. A couple of fast tugs and we both began to give her cumshots all over her face, some in her hair, and a lot in her mouth.

"Fuck, you two, that's a lot! In my hair, too!"

‘’Oops…’’ I laughed.

"You look sexier covered in that…" Kyle joked.

Surprisingly, she continued to lick both of us clean before wiping it off her face. All three of us then went up into the bathroom for a shower, Kyle tried fucking her again in there, but she wasn't having any of it.

"No, hunny, it was a one-off. I don't want our friendships ruined." She said while pushing him away.

We finished showering together. Kyle went downstairs first. Jenny leaned in for a kiss with me and whispered in my ear.

"I still want to fuck you again, though, just no more threesomes." She said while walking off downstairs.

All three of us had our movie night, drinks, and snacks. It was a relaxing night. We both left in the morning when Jenny messaged me, saying she wants us to be fucked buddies but doesn't want Kyle to know. It's a tough situation for me as Kyle is my best mate. I usually tell him everything, but well, Jenny is one sexy woman so for now, I am going to go ahead and keep it from Kyle, then see how things go.